Well first, I'd like to go through his pokemon.
In game.. he has:
Turtwig->Grotle->Torterra/ Chimchar->Monferno->Infernape/ Piplup->Prinplup->Empoleon
Starly->Staravia->Staraptor
Roselia->Roserade/ Buizel->Floatzel/ Ponyta->Rapidash
Heracross
Munchlax->Snorlax
Now I'd like to start by saying that this is a character that I really like. Actually, All of his pokemon (other than the Ponyta line) are among my TOP favortites. In fact, when my friend got Diamond (way before I got Pearl) he named his rival after me and we were shocked to find out that he had so many of "my" pokemon. So I've always felt a certain draw towards this character, and am excited to see him appear.
However, what Pokemon he has is a problem.
As for Turtwig (and by then, apparently Grotle
(I really like Grotle but dont think Ash's turtwig should evolve for many reasons) ) and Torterra, Ash and Paul already own them respectlivly.
There is a posibility of him having someone in the Chimchar line, probably not Chimchar since Ash already has his. I really hope he doesn't, as it will destroy all chances of Chimchar evolving if he does actually become a legitimate rival.
Piplup and Prinplup (probably later evolving to Empoleon) are owned by Dawn and Kenny, and a person with an Empoleon would be overkill.
Starly line will probably be owned in full by Ash, and Reggie had a Staraptor too.
For Roselia and Roserade, Drew and Nando have already had both, and unprominant they are now, they CANT do it again. Please.
Buizel is owned by Ash, and may evolve so no Floatzel (it will kill Ash's chances.)
Ponyta or Rapidash is a good posibility. No problems here.
Ash already has Heracross, but it wouldn't be terrible to see another one. Preferably not though.
May already had Munchlax, but we have not seen any much in its native Sinnoh. I would have no problems with this, but no Snorlax (Ash owned again).
So that leaves us (by my opinions) with:
Chimchar line member (please no)
Ponyta line (but lets remeber he can not have one of this line AND a Chimchar family member, its not possible in the game.)
Heracross (but hopefully they can just choose someone else)
and Munchlax (should be good)
Now other Pokemon I see fitting him are:
Leafeon (I'd rather someone else, mabye Dawn, get this though), Gallade (Id rather somebody like Kenny get this though), Chatot (I think Ive heard he has this in the Manga), and Rhyhorn (just sorta fits him for some reason). Snorunt or Mothim could be other inventive options too.
Aside from him being a rival, how about him being a rival researcher to Gary. That could be interesting for sure!
Or what about a guy who is looking to build a strong team of SHINY pokemon. Thatd be a good game mechanic for him to display too.
Well, this should be very interesting and I wait to see how this plays out.
;388;;391;;394; ;397; ;315;;419; ;214;;446;